San Antonio Businesswoman Receives 87-Month Sentence for Mail Fraud Scheme

San Antonio Businesswoman Sentenced to 87 Months for Mail Fraud

In a courtroom that felt heavy with tension, Samantha L. Mueting, a 59-year-old former business leader from San Antonio, learned her fate on Tuesday. After pleading guilty to conspiracy to commit mail fraud, Mueting was sentenced to an impressive 87 months in federal prison. This decision comes as the result of a complex scheme that left several investors reeling from significant financial losses, all stemming from what was marketed as a lucrative real estate investment fund.

Details of the Scheme

Mueting was the founder and chief executive of iCore Global LLC, which, according to her, was managing “hundreds of billions of dollars,” and claimed to employ thousands of people globally. But the truth was far less glamorous—her operation was essentially a front with no more than a handful of employees, and she was using a UPS store in Helotes as the address of incorporation.

The fallout has been severe, as Mueting also faces the daunting task of repaying her victims—over $4 million to be exact. The damage has left some investors with their savings wiped out, and the judge made it clear that such actions wouldn’t go unpunished. “She’s not going home tonight,” said U.S. District Judge Jason Pulliam as he delivered the sentence, ensuring that the weight of her actions set in.

A Last-Minute Attempt

Interestingly, just before her sentencing, Mueting attempted to withdraw her plea, claiming she was “actually innocent.” She argued that her previous lawyer hadn’t properly informed her about the plea agreement, stating she struggled to understand the document due to needing glasses at the time. However, Judge Pulliam was skeptical, noting that her testimony “just strains credulity.”

Her defense attorney, R. Scott Shearer, argued for a lighter sentence, insisting that Mueting never used investor money for her personal gain and that her intentions were to invest wisely. Unfortunately for her, the prosecution pointed out otherwise, emphasizing that some of the funds had indeed been diverted for personal expenses like credit card payments.

The Judge’s Perspective

Judge Pulliam acknowledged that, under normal circumstances, he might consider a lighter sentence to allow Mueting to start making restitution payments sooner. However, he reflected on what he termed a “stunning failure to accept responsibility” on her part. He mentioned that in his five years on the bench, he hadn’t seen such a lack of accountability, leading him to impose the maximum possible sentence.

Co-Defendant Sentenced

As the legal proceedings wrapped up, attention also turned to Josephus De Laat, iCore’s former chief financial officer, who received a less severe sentence of five years probation after pleading guilty to conspiracy to commit wire fraud. De Laat expressed regret for his partnership with Mueting, telling the judge, “In the end, I really wish I never had associated with Ms. Mueting.”

A Lesson Learned?

This entire episode serves as a stark reminder of the potential consequences of financial misconduct. Trust is a precious commodity in the world of investments, and for Mueting and her victims, the lessons learned span both ethical and legal realms. With an 87-month prison sentence looming over her, Mueting will have some time to reflect on her actions and their impact on the lives of those who believed in her.

As the dust settles, it’s clear that the repercussions of financial fraud extend far beyond the courtroom. They ripple through communities and livelihoods, serving as a cautionary tale about the importance of transparency and honesty in business.